When Markets Shake: 5 Practical Tips for Retirement Plan Sponsors
Every plan sponsor knows the feeling. The headlines turn grim, the market dives, and by lunchtime someone is standing in your doorway asking whether they should move everything to cash. You’re not their financial advisor, and you can’t promise the market will bounce back next week. But as the sponsor of your company’s retirement plan, you do have a real role to play, and it’s a steadier one than you might think. Good plan sponsors don’t predict markets. They communicate, they lean on smart plan design, and they follow a careful, documented process. Here are five pieces of practical advice from experts who know the terrain, each with one simple to-do.
1. Speak up early, and keep it calm
“Communicating right away goes a long way,” says Kelli Send, co-founder and senior vice president of financial wellness services at Francis LLC, in PLANSPONSOR. Silence makes people more anxious, she notes, but so does sounding an alarm. A short, steady note from leadership, reminding employees the plan is built for the long haul and pointing them to the guidance already available through your advisor or recordkeeper, does more than you’d think.
To-do: Draft your “the markets are bumpy” message now, so it’s ready before you need it.
2. Let plan design do the heavy lifting
Jeffrey W. Clark, head of defined contribution research at Vanguard, studied more than 20 years of participation data and found “no correlation to any economic or market volatility—only to plan designs.” In other words, automatic enrollment, automatic escalation, and professionally managed options like target-date funds keep people saving when emotions run hot. By the end of 2024, 67% of Vanguard plan participants were in a professionally managed allocation.
To-do: Ask your advisor which automatic features fit your plan and your workforce.
3. Look out for employees closest to retirement
When markets drop, nervous savers tend to bail out of stocks and come back late. As Rob Austin, head of thought leadership at Alight Solutions, put it to PLANADVISER: “they’re selling low, buying high. Not the perfect recipe for investing.” Remember, a paper loss only becomes real when someone sells. Austin points to automatic rebalancing, which he said about 70% of plans offer but only about 10% of participants use. Near-retirees also want someone to run their numbers, and PNC found one-on-one sessions work best.
To-do: Promote personal guidance sessions to employees within about 10 years of retirement.
4. Review, don’t react
Rocky markets are a good reason to look at your fund lineup more closely and more often. But a slumping fund isn’t automatically a fund to drop. David Kaleda, a principal with Groom Law Group, told NAPA that fiduciaries should find out why an investment is lagging, then “make a reasoned determination as to whether a change should be made.”
To-do: Schedule an investment check-in with your advisor, and use a watch list instead of reflexive cuts.
5. Write it all down
In June 2026, the Third Circuit sided with Quest Diagnostics’ plan fiduciaries in a lawsuit over underperforming funds. As Judge Stephanos Bibas wrote, summarized by law firm Nixon Peabody: “Nor do fiduciaries need crystal balls.” What won the day was process. The committee met regularly, got fiduciary training, hired an advisor and questioned its recommendations, and documented why it made each decision. Its investment policy statement used flexible “may” language, which preserved its discretion.
To-do: Keep minutes for every investment decision: what you reviewed, what you decided, and why.
Good To Know
Your employees may be more rattled than they let on. In a PNC survey of plan participants during the first half of 2026, more than half said they were considering cutting their retirement contributions, yet fewer than one in four planned to seek financial guidance. And EBRI’s 2026 Retirement Confidence Survey found worker confidence slipped to 61%, down from 67% a year earlier.
Volatility tests nerves, and it can invite blame. As we noted in Wondering What’s Next?, anxious participants may look for someone to hold responsible, and even a claim with no merit is costly to defend. For more on helping participants stay steady with their retirement savings, see Market Volatility and Retirement Plans and Homework Season: Retirement Plan Sponsorship.
Steady Protection, Fast
Markets will do what markets do. Your protection, however, should never wobble. When participants are anxious, a claim that you mismanaged the plan can land even if you did everything right, and ERISA defense attorneys bill upwards of $600 an hour. Colonial Surety Company’s ERISA bundle efficiently puts three layers of protection in place:
- ERISA fidelity bond: Required by federal law, it protects the plan itself against fraud or theft by anyone who handles plan funds.
- Fiduciary liability insurance: Protects you personally, with $1,000,000 for defense and penalties if you face alleged or actual breaches of fiduciary duty, such as claims about how you chose or monitored the plan’s investments.
- Cyber liability coverage: Covers the business and the plan, addresses several Department of Labor cybersecurity recommendations, and includes expert response services to limit damage after an incident.
Why Choose Colonial Surety Company for ERISA Protection?
Founded in 1930, Colonial Surety Company is rated “A” (Excellent) by A.M. Best and listed on U.S. Treasury Circular 570. For 401(k) plan sponsors, trustees, and retirement plan committees, our ERISA bundle combines the federally required ERISA fidelity bond, fiduciary liability insurance, and cyber liability coverage, and it’s the fastest way to get all three. Quote online in minutes and have coverage in place the same day. A 3-year option locks in your rate, and your bond automatically adjusts as your plan grows. Customers rate Colonial Surety Company 4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot across more than 6,000 verified reviews.
Helpful Resources
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)