Can a Trustee Say No? Handling Beneficiary Distribution Requests
Sooner or later, most trustees get the call: a beneficiary needs help with tuition, a medical bill or a down payment, or wants an advance before the holidays. Does the trustee have to say yes? Not necessarily, but a trustee can’t say no on a whim, either. Every distribution decision has to follow the trust’s terms, be made in good faith, account for every beneficiary, and be documented. Fortunately, as Casey Breese, a trust and fiduciary litigator at Lathrop GPM, observes, meeting those duties “is less about knowing every rule and more about good habits.”
Does a Trustee Have to Say Yes?
It depends on what the trust says. Some trusts require fixed distributions, such as paying out all income each quarter, and the trustee simply follows them. Many others give the trustee discretion, often tied to a standard like the beneficiary’s health, education, maintenance and support trustees to be “pointedly aware of the discretion afforded you” under the trust, and to weigh the grantor’s intent, such as a plan to provide for a beneficiary for life. Even sweeping language in the trust agreement, like “sole and absolute discretion,” isn’t a blank check for trustees. In the more than 30 states that have adopted a version of the Uniform Trust Code, a trustee must still use that discretion in good faith and in line with the trust’s purposes and the beneficiaries’ interests.
What Should a Trustee Ask Before Deciding?
According to Breese, acting reasonably starts with knowing the beneficiaries and what they actually need. Questions worth asking first:
- What is the money for, and is there paperwork to support it, such as a tuition statement, medical invoice or purchase contract?
- Does that purpose fit the trust’s distribution standard?
- Has something changed, such as a job loss or health crisis, that affects the beneficiary’s support needs?
- Do the trust terms or state law call for considering the beneficiary’s other income or assets?
- How would the payment affect the portfolio, cash on hand and taxes?
How Do Other Beneficiaries Factor In?
Under the duty of impartiality, Breese explains, a trustee must consider the best interests of current, remainder and contingent beneficiaries, and treat current beneficiaries fairly relative to one another. A generous payment to one adult child today may leave less for grandchildren named as remainder beneficiaries. It may also prompt a sibling to ask why a similar request was turned down last year.
Breese cautions against quickly reacting to changed circumstances before weighing every relevant issue. Impartial doesn’t mean identical, but any difference in treatment should be explainable under the trust’s terms.
What If the Trustee Is Family?
Family trustees know the beneficiaries’ history, which is both a strength and a risk. The duty of loyalty requires putting the beneficiaries’ interests ahead of the trustee’s own. Breese notes that a trustee cannot let personal bias, or a co-trustee’s bias, shape whether a distribution is made.
Old sibling tensions, frustration with a beneficiary’s spending, or a trustee who is also a beneficiary all call for extra care. Breese’s advice about following a consistent process, rather than reacting in the moment, is especially useful here. Additionally, a trustee with a personal stake in the outcome should talk with the trust’s attorney first.
How Should the Decision Be Documented and Shared?
Write it down, whether the answer is yes, no or not yet. A short memo should note the request, the trust language that applies, the information reviewed, the effect on other beneficiaries and the reasoning. Communicating decisions matters greatly too: trustees must keep all beneficials informed and respond to their questions in a timely manner. Attorneys at Frank & Kraft list poor communication among the common mistakes made by trustees and caution: “Failing to keep beneficiaries informed about significant trust matters may cause issues and result in personal liability for the Trustee.”
Good To Know: Where a Trustee Bond Fits
A sound process protects the trustee. A trustee bond protects the beneficiaries. If a trustee makes improper distributions, engages in self-dealing or otherwise fails to perform faithfully, the bond guarantees that beneficiaries can be compensated, up to the bond amount. Unlike insurance, a bond doesn’t shield the trustee: the trustee remains responsible for repaying the surety on valid claims. A trust agreement, a court or state law may require a trustee bond.
Get Bonded Quickly
Trustees: Direct, national bond writer, Colonial Surety Company makes it simple to get a trustee bond. Get a quote online, complete the application, and print or e-file the bond from anywhere.
Trust and estate attorneys: The Partnership Account® for Attorneys is a free service from Colonial Surety Company that makes client bonding easy and speedy. Just quote court and fiduciary bonds instantly, send them to clients for payment, and download or e-file them from your own private dashboard.
Sign Up for the Partnership Account® for Attorneys
In business since 1930, Colonial Surety Company is rated “A Excellent” by A.M. Best Company, U.S. Treasury listed, and licensed for business everywhere in the USA. Our customers have awarded us a 4.8 Trustpilot score.