Probate Dispute? Mediate First
When a loved one dies, probate is meant to bring order to their affairs. Under court supervision, debts and taxes are paid, and remaining assets are distributed according to the will or, absent one, state intestacy laws. But grief, stress and poor communication can stir things up. Sibling misunderstandings, questions about the will, mistrust of the executor and long-simmering conflicts can surface all at once, turning a routine process into probate litigation, a notoriously messy, slow and expensive detour that leaves the estate unsettled while legal fees chip away at it. Is a courtroom the only way out? Usually not. Many probate courts and attorneys steer families to mediation first, and it works far more often than not.
Mediation: Confidential Negotiations Resulting In Settlement
Warner Norcross + Judd partners Laura Morris and David L.J.M. Skidmore don’t hedge in their field notes from the mediation table: “Mediation resolves the vast majority of probate disputes.” Writing in the Michigan Bar Journal, Skidmore adds that even when relationships are highly contentious, his experience is that mediation produces a settlement more often than not. Some probate courts build it right into their scheduling orders.
Here’s how it typically works, as the firm explains in Mediation in Probate Court. A neutral mediator, usually an attorney trained in the process, helps the parties reach their own settlement. A full day is set aside, and the parties often sit in separate rooms while the mediator carries proposals back and forth.
Nobody can be forced to agree to anything. Instead, a skilled mediator helps each side weigh the risk of losing at trial against the cost of continuing to fight, and may offer each party “a private and frank assessment” of where its case stands. The negotiations stay confidential; the court is simply told whether the case settled.
Field Notes From the Probate Mediation Table
Mediation isn’t magic, though. In Tips for a Successful Mediation, Morris and Skidmore share nine best practices that can decide whether a long day ends with a signed agreement. Three stand out.
Bring the real decision-makers. Anyone who will influence a party’s decision belongs in the room, so they buy into the process instead of becoming “an 11th-hour obstacle by phone.”
Make it binding. The settlement should address any documents still to be signed and how disputes over its terms will be handled, and make clear it’s a binding contract, not an “agreement to agree.”
Include everyone with a stake. Other interested persons in the probate proceeding should be invited so they’re bound by the deal. If some don’t attend, making the agreement subject to probate court approval binds them too.
The rest of their advice is helpful and practical too: choose a mediator who knows probate and, ideally, the court involved; research tax issues in advance; have the mediator put every offer in writing; and plan for a long day, because an agreement should be signed before anyone goes home. Read the full list here.
After the Handshake: Getting the Estate Moving Again
Including everyone with a stake matters more than it might seem. In his Michigan Bar Journal piece, Skidmore points out that an interested person who skips mediation and later objects to the settlement may find the probate court unsympathetic, precisely because they passed on the chance to participate.
Once a settlement is signed, and approved by the court where needed, the personal representative for the estate (sometimes called the executor) can get back to their actual duties: inventorying assets, paying debts and taxes, and distributing what remains. The fiduciary duties don’t stop because the family made peace. If anything, a settlement often adds specific tasks the personal representative must carry out on a timeline.
It’s also worth remembering what tends to start these fights. Justia lists “sibling rivalry, second marriages, and dysfunctional families” among the high-risk factors for probate problems. And as we noted in Court Battles: Probate Litigation, a disorganized or incommunicative executor, or two co-fiduciaries who don’t get along, can raise the odds too. Clear, steady communication with beneficiaries is still the best prevention.
Need a Probate Bond? Get It Done Today.
Whether the family needs to get to the mediation table or the estate is moving through probate without a hitch, a court-ordered bond shouldn’t be what holds things up. Colonial Surety Company writes probate bonds, and every kind of fiduciary bond, to the specifications of obligees in every state. Quote online, purchase in minutes, and print or e-file from anywhere.
Attorneys, Bonds on Your Schedule: Meetings and mediations that run well past 5 p.m. shouldn’t mean a bond request waits until morning. The Partnership Account® for Attorneys gives you direct, digital access to Colonial Surety Company’s full portfolio of fiduciary and court bonds. Log in anytime, get a quote, send it to your client for payment, then download and file the bond on the spot. The portfolio covers administrator, executor, personal representative, probate, guardian, conservator and trustee bonds, plus appeal, supersedeas, injunction and other court bonds.
Open Your Partnership Account® for Attorneys
In business since 1930, Colonial Surety Company is a national insurance, ERISA fidelity and surety bond provider. We are licensed in all 50 states and U.S. territories, listed by the U.S. Treasury as an approved surety, and rated “A” Excellent by A.M. Best Company.
